Should we launch a podcast about high-impact projects and people?
By Robert_Wiblin @ 2014-12-01T16:52 (+9)
An idea I have repeatedly returned to is creating a podcast where I, or someone else, interviews people who are trying to work on high impact projects. It would cover questions like how they decided what to work on, and what practical challenges they face day-to-day.
Mixing a complicated radio show is very time consuming, so I think I would model it on my favourite podcast, EconTalk, which is a straightforward two-person interview. The main overhead is learning about the person's work ahead of time so that the conversation flows smoothly and the answers are actually interesting.
Reasons in favour
- It will allow us to meet and learn from people trying to have a large impact across a range of different causes and projects. I am concerned that effective altruism is too insular and does not take enough interest in mainstream professionals and experts, and this could help address that. I also think we invest too little in learning how to actually implement things well, relative to doing theoretical prioritisation research.
- There are not many highly informative podcasts out there. If this turns out to be interesting to listen to, it could attract a decent listenership, particularly of the kinds of people we are most keen to get involved.
- I am excited at the prospect, so it's likely it would actually happen, and I would probably enjoy working on it.
- It will take a significant investment of time and attention to do well.
- As I don't know anyone with radio or podcasting experience, it is likely to come across as amateurish at first.
- GiveWell already has something like this on their 'Conversations' page. On the other hand, these interviews are not designed to be entertaining or accessible, and so I doubt they are read or listened to by many people.
- Would this be a good use of my or someone else's time?
- If so, would you be interested in helping schedule these conversations, turn the recordings into podcast episodes, and perhaps later take over doing the interviews yourself?
undefined @ 2014-12-01T18:20 (+6)
I would listen to this podcast! I also think it would be helpful to other people and a good promotional tool for EA (podcasts are highly underrepresented compared to blogs in EA).
I think you could easily avoid overlapping with GiveWell's conversations.
You could probably arrange to meet someone who has radio/podcasting experience and would be interested in helping get things set up.
undefined @ 2014-12-04T20:58 (+4)
I can put you in contact with an EA who has experience with podcasts if you would like.
undefined @ 2014-12-02T00:57 (+2)
I would listen to the podcast, and I also think it is worth spending some time on. The closest thing I listen to is Development Drums (http://developmentdrums.org/) which is excellent and technically fairly simple, following a very similar format to the one you have suggested.
It's definitely worth thinking about how what you are doing would be different to what other EA groups are doing, and not just other podcasts but also other media through which various groups publish. My suggestion would be that it is something which is less explicitly EA than something like this forum, than Giving What We Can, than the facebook group - because there are already forums for the EA core to discuss issues and a podcast is unlikely to be the best environment for it in any case, and because I think we want to be reaching related groups rather than just ourselves (the sorts of movements that people who studied economics, philosophy or social science at university or who identify as generally progressive/left politically). I like the idea of a broader range of topics than current full time EA groups are investigating. Maybe (if you are doing it), it could overlap with OvercomingBias?
undefined @ 2014-12-01T23:45 (+2)
1) I think this is a good use of time, because podcasts are an increasingly relevant medium and I don't know of any that fill the niche you are looking for.
2) I have recently been planning a podcast of my own along almost exactly the same vein, taking inspiration from EconTalk as well as The Tim Ferriss Show (which involves interviews with "peak performers" and other highly successful people to see how they work).
I do not have podcasting experience but I have listened to numerous podcasts for inspiration and in classic EA fashion I've been overthinking the heck out of it, so if you are interested I can share my thoughts with you directly. I have also invested in a microphone and basic editing software to record some initial conversations and test the waters. Very low profile and preliminary right now, you can probably find better, but I am here and willing to lend my manpower.
undefined @ 2014-12-01T22:02 (+2)
You might consider having a look at http://www.flamingswordofjustice.com/ . It's a podcast of interviews with activists of various types (pretty left-wing). I've listened to a few episodes and found it interesting. It was the closest thing I could think of that already exists.